Disney World Resorts – Stay Once and You’re Done!

We’ve all heard the phrase, “You have to try everything at least once,” and at Walt Disney World Resort, that can certainly apply to its incredible variety of hotels. With over 20 resorts, ranging from Value to Deluxe, it’s tempting to explore each one.

But after trying some of the more well-known hotels, many guests find themselves thinking, “Once was enough!” Whether it’s because of price, amenities, or just a different vibe than expected, there are certain Disney hotels that guests may stay in once but not return to for future trips.

Here’s a look at a few Walt Disney World Resort hotels that, while they offer something special, might be a one-and-done experience for many Disney fans.

Disney’s Art of Animation Resort

Let’s kick off with one of the most visually striking resorts at Walt Disney World—Disney’s Art of Animation Resort. This Value Resort opened in 2012 and is famous for its immersive theming, inspired by Disney classics like The Little Mermaid, The Lion King, Finding Nemo, and Cars. Everywhere you look, larger-than-life characters make you feel like you’ve stepped into a Disney movie.

While this resort is a must-see for families and animation fans, there are a few reasons why guests might only stay here once. First, the price. Despite being categorized as a Value Resort, the family suites, which are available in most sections of the resort, tend to be pricier than even some Moderate Resorts. If you’re traveling with a large group, the suites are spacious and convenient, but smaller families or couples may find the cost a bit steep compared to other options.

Another downside is the location of the standard rooms in The Little Mermaid section. While these rooms offer a more budget-friendly option, they are far from the main amenities like the pool, lobby, and dining. After a long day at the parks, that extra walking can feel like a marathon, leaving many guests thinking they’ll opt for something a bit more centrally located next time.

Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort

Over at Disney’s Coronado Springs Resort, guests are treated to a vibrant blend of Spanish, Mexican, and Southwest American theming. The addition of Gran Destino Tower brought a touch of luxury to this Moderate Resort, complete with a club-level experience and upgraded dining options, including the highly-rated Toledo – Tapas, Steak & Seafood.

But, despite its elegance, many guests find that Coronado Springs doesn’t quite fit the bill for repeat visits. The resort is sprawling, with multiple bus stops that can make getting around a bit of a hassle. For guests without a car, the long walks to the bus stops or the resort’s amenities can get old fast, especially in the Florida heat.

Another factor to consider is the convention center located at Coronado Springs. While it’s great for business travelers, leisure guests might find the atmosphere a little less “vacation” and a bit more “work trip” when the resort is hosting large groups.

Disney’s Beach Club Resort

A Deluxe Resort with a prime location, Disney’s Beach Club Resort offers easy access to EPCOT and Disney’s Hollywood Studios, making it a popular choice for guests wanting to be close to the action. It also boasts one of the best pools on Disney property—Stormalong Bay—a mini water park shared with Disney’s Yacht Club Resort.

However, despite these perks, some guests find Beach Club lacking in areas that matter most. The resort’s theming is light and breezy, which some may interpret as charming, but others might feel it’s too subtle compared to other Deluxe Resorts. The guest rooms, while comfortable, don’t offer the same wow factor you’d expect at this price point.

For families with small kids, the atmosphere might feel a bit too laid back compared to the more exciting theming at resorts like Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort or Disney’s Wilderness Lodge. After experiencing Stormalong Bay, some guests may feel they’ve seen all the Beach Club has to offer and will look elsewhere for future stays.

Disney’s Contemporary Resort

When it comes to classic Disney hotels, few are as iconic as Disney’s Contemporary Resort. Opened in 1971, this Deluxe Resort is famous for its modern A-frame design, its proximity to Magic Kingdom, and, of course, the monorail passing right through the building. It’s home to popular dining spots like Chef Mickey’s and California Grill, and offers stunning views of the Magic Kingdom fireworks.

But despite its legendary status, many guests stay at the Contemporary once and feel that’s enough. One of the main reasons is the price—this is one of Disney’s most expensive resorts, and for many guests, it doesn’t offer enough to justify the high cost. Yes, it’s convenient for Magic Kingdom, but if you’re planning on visiting EPCOT, Disney’s Hollywood Studios, or Animal Kingdom, you’re in for longer transit times.

The Contemporary also lacks the immersive theming found at other Deluxe Resorts. While its sleek, modern design appeals to some, others feel it’s missing that Disney magic. After ticking it off their Disney bucket list, many guests choose to stay elsewhere on future visits, where the theming and experience feel more worth the cost.

Disney’s Saratoga Springs Resort & Spa

As one of Disney’s Vacation Club properties, Disney’s Saratoga Springs Resort & Spa offers a relaxed, Victorian-style experience inspired by the historic Saratoga Springs in New York. With sprawling grounds, golf courses, and easy access to Disney Springs, it’s a peaceful retreat away from the hustle and bustle of the parks.

But for some guests, that very sense of serenity can also feel a bit too far removed. Saratoga Springs is a massive resort, and navigating it can be confusing and time-consuming, especially if your room is located far from the main lobby or dining options. If you’re looking to be in the heart of the Disney magic, this resort’s quiet vibe might not cut it.

While it’s a favorite for DVC members who enjoy the spacious rooms and tranquil setting, non-DVC guests often stay here once and then opt for resorts with easier park access and more immersive Disney theming on future visits.

Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort

Rounding out our list is Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort, a Moderate Resort with vibrant island theming, hammocks on the beach, and access to the Disney Skyliner. It’s one of the largest Moderate Resorts, and for many guests, that’s where the problem lies.

With multiple bus stops and long walks between rooms and amenities, Caribbean Beach can feel overwhelming. Even though the Skyliner provides quick access to EPCOT and Disney’s Hollywood Studios, the size of the resort often means guests have to budget extra time just to get to the station.

Theming-wise, while the resort is colorful and fun, it doesn’t stand out as much compared to others like Port Orleans Riverside or French Quarter. Once guests have experienced the novelty of Caribbean Beach, they often prefer a more compact resort for future trips.

Conclusion

There’s no doubt that each of these Disney resorts offers something special and unique, but after one stay, many guests find themselves ready to try something new. Whether it’s the resort’s size, price, or theming, these hotels often land in the “once was enough” category.

What do you think? Have you stayed at any of these resorts and feel the same, or are any of them your go-to favorite? Let us know which Disney resorts you’d stay at again—and which ones you’d happily skip on your next visit!