DisneyTips.com Your Guide To A Great Disney Vacation
Nestled between Frontierland and Liberty Square in Disney’s Magic Kingdom, you’ll find one of the park’s most underrated dining spots: The Diamond Horseshoe. This charming, all-you-can-eat table-service restaurant offers hearty American fare at a surprisingly reasonable price well, reasonable by Disney standards.
Despite its prime location and delicious offerings, Diamond Horseshoe remains one of the least talked about restaurants in the park. But that’s exactly why it’s a hidden gem worth discovering on your next visit.
Let’s dive into why this Old West-themed dining spot deserves a place on your Magic Kingdom itinerary.
A Restaurant with a Shifting Identity
The Diamond Horseshoe’s lack of popularity can be largely attributed to its ever-changing identity over the years. Originally, this restaurant was a lively dinner show reminiscent of the Hoop-Dee-Doo Revue, complete with live performances, Western-themed antics, and classic American comfort food.
However, as Disney evolved, so did this venue. It shifted to a quick-service restaurant, which ultimately didn’t resonate well with guests.
Credit: Disney
After a few lackluster years in its new format, Diamond Horseshoe was closed and remained dormant for some time. It looked like this once-loved restaurant might shut its doors for good. But Diamond Horseshoe wasn’t down for long. Disney gave it a fresh new life as an all-you-can-eat table-service restaurant, which pleased fans of hearty, American-style comfort food.
Still, it faced yet another hurdle when it was reduced to seasonal operation, making it a bit elusive, especially for off-season visitors.
Luckily, Diamond Horseshoe is now back in full operation, offering a satisfying dining experience for anyone craving a taste of the Old West. It may have had its ups and downs, but this restaurant is better than ever and ready to serve you a feast.
Familiar Menu with Comfort Food Classics
If you’re a fan of Liberty Tree Tavern, Diamond Horseshoe’s menu will feel like home. The two restaurants share nearly identical menus, offering classic comfort foods that are perfect for a family-style meal. This makes Diamond Horseshoe an excellent alternative if you’re struggling to snag a reservation at Liberty Tree Tavern, especially during busy times like Thanksgiving.
With fewer crowds and the same mouth-watering dishes, it’s a win-win situation.
What to Expect on the Menu
To start your meal, you’ll be treated to a fresh garden salad with Chipotle ranch dressing, accompanied by warm dinner rolls. While the bread may not be anything extraordinary, the zesty salad more than makes up for it, prepping your palate for the hearty meal ahead.
Credit: Disney
For the main course, there are two all-you-can-eat platters to choose from: the traditional Frontier Feast and the Plant-Based Cowpoke Platter.
- The Frontier Feast includes:
- Roasted Turkey
- Pennsylvania Pot Roast
- Oven-roasted Pork
- Mashed Potatoes
- Seasonal Vegetables
- Herb Stuffing
- House-made Macaroni & Cheese
To finish off this comforting meal, you’ll be delighted with the famous Ooey Gooey Toffee Cake, a dessert that has earned a loyal fan base at Disney.
- The Plant-Based Cowpoke Platter features:
- Plant-based Meatloaf served with mashed potatoes
- Mushroom Gravy
- Seasonal Vegetables
Dessert for the plant-based option is Johnny Appleseed’s Warm Apple Cake, a delightful sweet treat that’s just as satisfying as the toffee cake.
Why Diamond Horseshoe Should Be on Your Disney Dining List
The Diamond Horseshoe offers an all-you-can-eat experience at a reasonable price, making it one of the better deals in Magic Kingdom. Pricing is identical to Liberty Tree Tavern: $39 for adults and $21 for children, whether you’re dining for lunch or dinner.
When deciding between the two, it really comes down to theming and availability. The menu items are nearly the same, so if you can’t score a reservation at one, try the other. Both offer a hearty meal that will leave you more than satisfied.
But beyond the food, Diamond Horseshoe also excels in service. Guests are welcomed with a cheerful Western flair, greeted with a hearty “howdy,” and served by friendly cast members who fully embrace the Old West atmosphere. The servers add a bit of playful banter, asking which “grub pile ya want,” adding to the immersive dining experience.
Credit: Disney
Additionally, the service tends to be quicker than at some other Magic Kingdom restaurants, which is a huge plus if you’re looking to maximize your park time. With so many attractions to see, shows to catch, and rides to experience, a faster meal means more time for fun.
Western-themed Atmosphere with Disney Magic
When you step inside The Diamond Horseshoe, you’ll be transported to an Old West saloon, complete with rustic wooden décor and charming details that make you feel like you’ve stepped into a scene from the frontier.
The highlight of the restaurant is the self-playing piano on the main stage, which adds to the lively atmosphere. The setting feels authentic yet lighthearted, which is perfect for families looking to escape the hustle and bustle of the park and enjoy a leisurely meal.
Though it doesn’t boast character dining or live shows like other Disney restaurants, Diamond Horseshoe’s atmosphere offers a relaxed, cozy space to enjoy some classic American fare.
Why Diamond Horseshoe is a Hidden Gem
Despite being in a prime location at Magic Kingdom, Diamond Horseshoe remains somewhat of a hidden gem. It doesn’t have the same reputation as Be Our Guest or Cinderella’s Royal Table, and it rarely tops the list of must-visit Disney restaurants. However, this lack of popularity is part of its charm. You’re less likely to encounter massive crowds, making it easier to get a reservation.
For those looking for a great meal without the hassle, this is the perfect spot to take a break and refuel before heading back into the excitement of Frontierland and Liberty Square.
Final Thoughts
If you’re planning a trip to Magic Kingdom, consider making a reservation at The Diamond Horseshoe. Not only will you enjoy hearty, delicious food, but you’ll also experience a piece of Disney history with its Western-themed décor and Old West ambiance. With quick service, fewer crowds, and a comfortable setting, this restaurant offers a refreshing alternative to some of the park’s busier dining spots.
On your next Disney trip, why not give Diamond Horseshoe a try? You’ll be treated to a rootin’ tootin’ good time with great food and a memorable experience. Plus, you’ll leave with a full stomach and a smile, ready to tackle the rest of your magical day.
